The August West Grading System

While some of our pieces are graded and encapsulated by third-party companies such as CGC, most of our historic pieces exist outside of those slabs. For works not formally graded, we have developed the August West Grading System — a qualitative framework designed to give you a clear understanding of how a piece will present when displayed.

This system is not meant to replace professional grading. Rather, it provides practical insight into visual impact, structural integrity, and collectability.

It’s also worth noting that many of our collectors actually prefer pieces with a bit of honest wear. Subtle signs of age — pinholes, edge wear, soft folds — often serve as quiet visual confirmation of authenticity to the discerning eye. Character is just part of the story.

 

1. Reference Grade

    • Severe damage, losses, or heavy restoration

    • Not suitable for traditional display without intervention

    • Sold strictly as a historical or study example

2. Display Grade

  • Heavy wear, staining, moderate size tears/repairs

  • Significant color fading, but still visually compelling when framed properly

  • Entry-level ownership of an original

  • Flaws contribute to authenticity and charm but are more apparent than at higher grades

3. Character Grade

  • Noticeable flaws: pinholes, edge wear, folds, light staining, small tears

  • Strong color

  • Structurally very sound

  • Flaws contribute to authenticity and charm

4. Fine Art Grade

  • Above-average condition for age

  • Clean presentation with minor, unobtrusive flaws not easily visible

  • Strong color and paper integrity

  • Suitable for high-end gallery display

5. Museum Grade

  • Exceptional preservation with no visible flaws

  • Outstanding color, margins, structural integrity

  • Institutional-quality piece